An electric power cycle engine that uses 8kW runs for only a few seconds on a 100MJ (27.75kWh) battery, instead of the expected ~3.4 hours.

Bug Done Found in 0.9.910.1 Fixed in 0.9.917.1
Sandbox View

6 Comments

  • Log in to leave a comment
  • Profile image
    Dev Pedro

    @bspawn Thanks for the data, I thought you meant the value dislplayed, not a mismatch between that and the amount drained. With it being exactly 1k it's pretty safe to assume I have a unit conversion error (kW instead of W) somewhere

    2.5 years ago
  • Profile image
    235 bspawn

    @Pedro
    Thank for the reply.

    "the consumption of the engines is based on real data. They aren't used on large crafts for a reason."

    I am using the electric power cycle engine on a very small low mass rocket, less than 1000kg. The first stage has a single electric power cycle engine that uses 6kW (11kN ASL).
    A battery needed to run it for 2 minutes is about as large and as heavy as the entire rocket without battery, and contains 1000 times as much Joules as one would expect.

    (I tested the batteries with lights; 6kW runs for 1 minute on 0.1kWh (360kJ) as expected)

    So the problem appears to be with electric power cycle engines.

    I have made another demonstration craft:
    - electric power cycle engine reports 6kW power usage
    - so it should run for 1 minute on a 0.1kWh (360kJ) battery
    - but it requires 100kWh (360MJ) ; that battery weighs more than the fuel required to run the engine for 1 minute and is almost as large as the fuel tank.

    2.5 years ago
  • Profile image

    Except the consumption is higher than what the numbers the game says. @Pedro

    2.5 years ago
  • Profile image
    Dev Pedro

    @bspawn @KellyNyanbinary the density of the batteries is a bit higher than lithium ion batteries, so better than the best commercial batteries currently available, and the consumption of the engines is based on real data. They aren't used on large crafts for a reason.

    2.5 years ago
  • Profile image

    Can confirm.

    2.6 years ago
  • Profile image
    235 bspawn
    2.6 years ago

4 Upvotes

Log in in to upvote this post.